SwiftUI is a powerful tool for building modern iOS apps, but it still has some quirks, especially when it comes to UI testing. One of the more frustrating issues you may encounter is the unintended accessibility identifier propagation in SwiftUI from container views to child views. This can make UI testing difficult, as multiple elements end up sharing the same identifier. In this post, I’ll explain this behavior and how to avoid it using a simple example.

The Problem: Accessibility Identifier Propagation in SwiftUI

When you set an accessibilityIdentifier on a container view (like a VStack or HStack), it can sometimes get propagated to all child elements inside that container. This causes confusion in your UI tests, where multiple elements unexpectedly share the same identifier, making it impossible to find or interact with individual elements.

Here’s a simplified example of how this problem occurs.

Example Code

import SwiftUI

struct ExampleView: View {
    var body: some View {
        VStack {
            Text("Hello, World!")
                .accessibilityIdentifier("example.text")

            Image(systemName: "star.fill")
                .accessibilityIdentifier("example.image")
            
            Button("Click Me") {
                print("Button tapped")
            }
            .accessibilityIdentifier("example.button")
        }
        .accessibilityIdentifier("example.container")
    }
}

In this code:

• The VStack has the identifier example.container.

• The Text, Image, and Button have their own unique identifiers.

However, when you run your UI tests, you’ll notice something strange: all the elements inside the VStack share the same identifier as the VStack itself — example.container. This is especially problematic when you’re trying to locate specific elements, such as the button, during your UI tests.

The Result in UI Tests

You might expect to find each UI element by its specific identifier. However, if you inspect the hierarchy during testing, you’ll see something like this:

StaticText, identifier: 'example.container', label: 'Hello, World!'
Image, identifier: 'example.container', label: 'star.fill'
Button, identifier: 'example.container', label: 'Click Me'

Instead of unique identifiers for each element, they all share the identifier of the parent VStack, making it impossible to interact with each element individually.

Why This Happens

This happens because accessibilityIdentifier can propagate down the view hierarchy if set at the container level. When you set an identifier on the parent view (like the VStack), it inadvertently overrides the identifiers of child views.

How to Fix It

The best solution is not to set accessibilityIdentifier on the container itself if the children need unique identifiers. Instead, set identifiers directly on the child elements and avoid setting them at the container level unless it’s absolutely necessary.

Here’s how you can refactor the code to avoid this problem:

import SwiftUI

struct ExampleView: View {
    var body: some View {
        VStack {
            Text("Hello, World!")
                .accessibilityIdentifier("example.text")

            Image(systemName: "star.fill")
                .accessibilityIdentifier("example.image")
            
            Button("Click Me") {
                print("Button tapped")
            }
            .accessibilityIdentifier("example.button")
        }
        // No accessibilityIdentifier on the container
    }
}

In this version, the VStack no longer has an accessibilityIdentifier, which prevents identifier propagation. Each child element has its own unique identifier that you can use in your UI tests.

The Importance of Accessibility Identifiers in UI Tests

Unique accessibilityIdentifiers are crucial for reliable UI tests. They allow you to directly locate and interact with specific elements, ensuring your tests are robust and easy to maintain. By understanding how accessibility identifier propagation works in SwiftUI and how to prevent it, you can avoid headaches and make your UI tests much more reliable.

Conclusion

Accessibility is a powerful tool in SwiftUI, especially for automated UI testing. However, as we’ve seen, setting accessibilityIdentifier on a container can sometimes cause unintended consequences by propagating to child views. By being mindful of where you set your identifiers and ensuring they are unique at the child element level, you can avoid many issues in your UI tests.

Have you encountered similar issues with accessibility identifiers in SwiftUI? Share your experiences or solutions in the comments below!

Key Takeaways:

• Avoid setting accessibilityIdentifier on container views if you need unique identifiers for child elements.

• Always inspect the view hierarchy in your UI tests to ensure identifiers are correctly applied.

• Use separate identifiers for child views to avoid conflicts and improve the reliability of your UI tests.

33